91海角乱伦 Students Take Shakespeare to the Courtroom

In this interdisciplinary legal studies course, students learned valuable law techniques while putting popular Shakespearean characters on trial

By Courtney Dell'Agnese '19
student giving opening statement in trial
Students give their opening statements to set the tone for the impending trial.

BRISTOL, R.I. 鈥 Many of us are used to seeing Shakespeare stories such as Hamlet and Macbeth reenacted time and time again on the theater stage. But in this interdisciplinary legal studies course, 13 students studied these popular tales from a whole new perspective and brought Shakespeare to the courtroom.

As an English literature major and attorney, assistant professor of legal studies Eve Brown aimed to combine her two passions while giving students real, hands-on experience with legal techniques such as direct questioning, closing arguments and cross-examining witnesses through a mock trial.

students preparing for mock trial
To prepare for trial, students studied and heavily analyzed Hamlet.

鈥淚 really believe students learn best by doing rather than just hearing and a lot of times when we give them exercises that simulate law, they鈥檙e kind of one-dimensional, hypothetical situations,鈥 Brown said. 鈥淚 thought if we brought literature into it and have that be the basis for mock trial, we have these characters with backgrounds and quotes and they have this whole wealth of literature critiquing Shakespeare and all this information they can draw from.鈥

From the first day of class, the students picked the characters they wished to prosecute, picked the theme and theory of their case and broke into prosecution and defense teams.

鈥淚 didn鈥檛 know anything about Hamlet, but I knew the mock trial aspect of it,鈥 said senior political science major Alivia Casillas who has also been a member of 91海角乱伦鈥檚 mock trial team for the last two years. 鈥淚 love everything about mock trial. When we get in there it鈥檚 just fun for me. The objections and breaking down case material, coming up with ulterior motives and poking holes, it鈥檚 a game for me and I love that aspect of trial.鈥

This year鈥檚 class chose to prosecute Claudius from Hamlet and Lady Macbeth from Macbeth. Both defendants pleaded not guilty.

Alivia Casillas helps prepare her witness for the mock trial
Students prepared their witnesses to answer questions while on the witness stand.

In order to create a true-to-life mock trial and give the students experience in working with individuals who don鈥檛 study law,91海角乱伦 professors, theater students and members from a Shakespeare reading group volunteered to take part as witnesses. To readily prepare them for trial, Brown鈥檚 students had to meet and coach the witnesses, go over each of their depositions and train them to properly answer questions when they鈥檙e on the stand.

For Casillas, who will be attending 91海角乱伦 Law next fall, taking part in these mock trials throughout her undergraduate career has given her a large amount of experience in the type of work she may be doing in the future, especially working with witnesses.

鈥淲ith the witnesses, I tried to give them tips on how to answer a question a certain way so they could prevent getting objected. But at the same time, it鈥檚 about knowing that in real life witnesses don鈥檛 know how trials work, they don鈥檛 know how court works,鈥 Casillas said. 鈥淭hings like objections, leading questions, directing and crossing, I would have had no idea what those were until I got into law school if it weren鈥檛 for mock trial. It鈥檚 definitely been a huge stepping stone for me."

student questions witness during mock trial
During the trials, students cross examined witnesses in order to plea their case. 

Brown鈥檚 main goal for the course was to show her students to start thinking like lawyers, getting them to problem solve, analyze, critically think and present persuasive arguments. But she also hopes the course goes beyond teaching her students the legal skills and shows them how much of an impact art can have, even when practicing law.

鈥淥nce you get to law school, even if you do mock trial it鈥檚 pretty structured in terms of giving you a hypothetical that has to do with law. Whereas with undergrad I think we have a bit more freedom to really delve into the liberal arts side and really be interdisciplinary,鈥 Brown said. 鈥淎rt reflects life and our emotions and I think it鈥檚 a good way to examine things like motivation and the human side of something. Where yes, you鈥檙e practicing law, but it鈥檚 also a story. Your clients have stories and you鈥檙e the one telling that story.鈥

As for the final verdicts, both Claudius and Lady Macbeth were found guilty of murder, and Brown鈥檚 students are walking away with the experience and skills they will need to succeed as future law practitioners.